Is there a right to civil disobedience?

Is there a right to civil disobedience?

democracies enjoy a moral right to engage in suitably constrained forms of civil disobedience which he calls ‘public disobedience’. The former does not include a claim-right against other forms of interference by the state such as forcible prevention or penalisation.

Is civil disobedience a right or a responsibility?

To be legally responsible is to observe the law. There- fore, civil disobedience and legal responsibility are mutually exclusive, since whoever is legally responsible never violates the law, and violation of the law is an essential property of civil disobedience.

Is civil disobedience needed Why or why not?

Civil disobedience is no nuisance to the public. Rather, it is an important, even necessary strategy for overcoming roadblocks to progress. It is an essential freedom, and a crucial resource for citizens of an organized society. A variety of arguments have been set forth by scholars in support of civil disobedience.

How did civil disobedience affect the civil rights movement?

Civil disobedience effective: if abolitionists withdrew their support of government, then slavery would end in a peaceful revolution. In 1955, a black woman named Rosa Parks was arrested for the crime of refusing to give up her bus seat to a white man. This incident sparked the civil rights movement.

How was the government involved in the civil rights movement?

The movement helped spawn a national crisis that forced intervention by the federal government to overturn segregation laws in southern states, restore voting rights for African-Americans, and end legal discrimination in housing, education and employment.

What is justification for civil disobedience?

To claim a right to civil disobedience is to claim that others have a duty to allow the agent to commit the act. Nonetheless it is justifiable to violate an immoral law (and even a moral law provided one is unable to violate the immoral law~ but would have been justified in doing so.)

What is the main idea of civil disobedience?

civil disobedience, also called passive resistance, the refusal to obey the demands or commands of a government or occupying power, without resorting to violence or active measures of opposition; its usual purpose is to force concessions from the government or occupying power.

Who was using civil disobedience movement as an element in the freedom movement?

Gandhi
A version was taken up by the author Henry David Thoreau in his essay Civil Disobedience, and later by Gandhi in his doctrine of Satyagraha. Gandhi’s Satyagraha was partially influenced and inspired by Shelley’s nonviolence in protest and political action.

Did the federal government support the civil rights movement?

The verdict was ‘a pivotal moment in southern history’ for African-Americans. [21] The federal government – in this case the Supreme Court – acted unambiguously in favour of the advancement of civil rights.

What are the consequences of civil disobedience?

Civil disobedience can easily spiral out of control if there are some nonviolent or aggressive people among the protestors. Breaking any law will defeat the purpose of the movement, get people imprisoned and there can be jail time involved. Civil disobedience can tarnish the legal history of a person in such cases. 2.

How can civil disobedience spiral out of control?

1. Civil disobedience can easily spiral out of control if there are some nonviolent or aggressive people among the protestors. Breaking any law will defeat the purpose of the movement, get people imprisoned and there can be jail time involved.

Is there a contradiction in the concept of Righteous civil disobedience?

Therefore, it seems to me that there is an inherent contradiction in the concept of premeditated, “righteous” civil disobedience. Yet I prefer to base the case on broader grounds. The concept of righteous civil disobedience, I think, is incompatible with the concept of the American legal system.

Is civil disobedience a positive or negative interest?

Civil disobedience will get you attention and it would be positive interest. Whenever someone engages in a violent protest or ends up damaging public property and hate mongering, it gets negative press. Civil disobedience will get you the attention of the press, public figures,…